The whispers of Asuka's semi-retirement have sent ripples through the wrestling world, prompting a look back at the incredible in-ring legacy she's carved out. It’s a moment to reflect on the sheer artistry and athleticism that the "Empress of Tomorrow" brought to the WWE, particularly when we consider the matches that have earned the highest praise from discerning eyes like Dave Meltzer.
A Legacy Forged in NXT
Personally, I think Asuka's initial run in NXT was nothing short of revolutionary for women's wrestling in the company. Her bout against Ember Moon at NXT TakeOver: Brooklyn III stands out as a masterclass. The four and a half stars Meltzer bestowed upon it isn't just a rating; it's a testament to a contest that felt both technically brilliant and emotionally charged. What makes this particular match so memorable, in my opinion, is the palpable chemistry between Asuka and Moon. They pushed each other to new heights, showcasing a level of in-ring storytelling that was, and still is, incredibly rare. It wasn't just about moves; it was about the narrative woven through every lock-up, every near-fall, and every strategic counter. This match, for me, solidified Asuka's status as a must-see performer.
Her encounters with Ember Moon didn't stop there, with their clash at NXT TakeOver: Orlando also earning a stellar four and a quarter stars. It's fascinating to see how their rivalry evolved, and how each subsequent match built upon the last. From my perspective, these early NXT battles were crucial in establishing Asuka's dominance and showcasing a style that was both unique and captivating.
Stepping Onto the Grandest Stage
When Asuka transitioned to the main roster, the expectations were sky-high, and she largely delivered. Her TLC 2018 triple threat match against Becky Lynch and Charlotte Flair, also rated four and a half stars, was a pivotal moment. This wasn't just a wrestling match; it was a statement. The fact that it headlined the pay-per-view speaks volumes about the respect she had earned. What I find particularly interesting about this match is how it showcased Asuka's ability to thrive in the chaotic, high-stakes environment of a TLC match. She proved she could hang with the best, not just in technical wrestling, but in brawling and hardcore elements too.
Even in defeat, her matches often left an indelible mark. The Women's WarGames match at Survivor Series 2023, where she was part of Damage CTRL, earned four and a half stars. While it was a team effort, Asuka's presence always elevates the action. It’s a testament to her enduring impact that even in a multi-person spectacle, her contributions are felt and appreciated. This match, in my view, highlights her adaptability and her ability to contribute to different match types and dynamics.
Rivalries That Defined Eras
One thing that immediately stands out is Asuka's incredible ability to have compelling matches with a variety of opponents. Her series of bouts with Rhea Ripley, including their Raw encounter rated four and a half stars, and their WrestleMania Backlash triple threat (four and a quarter stars), are prime examples. These matches were hard-hitting, intense, and showcased a clash of styles that was incredibly compelling. What this suggests to me is that Asuka has a rare gift for elevating her opponents and creating memorable moments, even when she isn't the one walking away with the victory.
Her inclusion in the Hell in a Cell 2022 triple threat against Becky Lynch and Bianca Belair, rated four stars, further solidifies her place among the elite. Even in a landscape often dominated by other narratives, Asuka consistently finds a way to deliver a performance worthy of recognition. This match, in my opinion, demonstrates her resilience and her unwavering commitment to putting on a show.
Early Promise and Lasting Impact
Looking back, even her earliest WWE matches showed immense promise. Her NXT London bout against Emma in 2015, earning four stars, was a significant early indicator of the talent she possessed. It was a confident debut that immediately signaled her arrival as a serious contender. Furthermore, her Last Woman Standing match against Nikki Cross on NXT, also rated four stars, was a brutal and captivating encounter that underscored her toughness and willingness to go the extra mile. These matches, though perhaps less celebrated than some of her later work, are crucial in understanding the foundation of her incredible career.
What this list truly highlights, beyond individual ratings, is Asuka's remarkable consistency and her profound impact on women's wrestling within WWE. Her ability to connect with audiences, deliver breathtaking performances, and earn the respect of critics and fans alike is a legacy that will endure, regardless of her current status. It makes me wonder what other incredible matches might exist just outside this top 10, and what further chapters could have been written if circumstances were different.
